OceanGate CEO Criticizes Excessive Rules Imposed by Certifying Agencies

**Submersible Design Criticized by James Cameron**

Stockton Rush, CEO and founder of OceanGate, faced criticism for the design of the Titan submersible. Notably, filmmaker and ocean explorer James Cameron publicly expressed his disapproval, calling the carbon fiber design “completely inappropriate” and “a horrible idea.”

**Titan Submersible Implodes on Journey to Titanic Shipwreck**

Tragically, the Titan submersible suffered a catastrophic implosion while en route to the Titanic shipwreck. As a result, all five passengers on board are presumed lost. The U.S. Coast Guard confirmed this devastating incident.

**Certification Programs for Submersibles**

During a GeekWire summit in October, Stockton Rush discussed the challenges of certification for submersibles like the Titan. He highlighted the strict rules and regulations imposed by certifying or semi-certifying agencies. However, these programs did not have specific guidelines for carbon fiber materials. Rush acknowledged the difficulties of pushing the boundaries of innovation and remarked on the need for a comprehensive understanding of limitations.

**Certification Urged but Unfulfilled**

Despite recommendations from experts, the Titan submersible was never certified. Rob McCallum, who operates an ocean expedition company, communicated with Rush about the importance of certification. McCallum raised concerns about the potential danger associated with the submersible’s operation. He drew comparisons to the ill-fated Titanic, cautioning Rush against overconfidence. However, Rush dismissed safety arguments and asserted that he was qualified to assess the risks and challenges of subsea exploration.

**Legal Threats and Disagreements**

In the exchange between McCallum and Rush, tensions escalated when OceanGate’s lawyers threatened legal action. McCallum emphasized the significance of classing, testing, and proving the submersible before engaging in commercial deep dive operations. He urged Rush to prioritize caution and adopt a conservative approach. McCallum emphasized the need to protect the entire industry from unnecessary risks. However, Rush maintained his confidence in his qualifications and understanding of subsea exploration.

**Innovation Challenges and Rule-Breaking**

Stockton Rush expressed his unconventional approach to submersible design. He admitted to breaking traditional engineering rules by incorporating carbon fiber and titanium materials in the Titan’s construction. In a 2021 interview, Rush spoke about the rule-breaking nature of his design choices. Despite the risks associated with deviating from established engineering principles, he pursued innovation and pushed the boundaries of conventional practices.

**Lessons Learned and the Future of Submersible Safety**

McCallum stressed the importance of adhering to sound engineering principles based on experience. He emphasized that failure to prioritize safety when designing submersibles can result in tragic consequences. McCallum expressed the need for stricter regulations to prevent similar incidents from occurring in the future, protecting both industry professionals and passengers.

In conclusion, the Titan submersible’s carbon fiber design faced criticism and ultimately led to a catastrophic implosion during its journey to the Titanic shipwreck. Despite recommendations for certification and concerns about safety, OceanGate did not fulfill this requirement. The exchange between Rob McCallum and Stockton Rush highlighted the divergent views regarding safety and innovation. While Rush defended his rule-breaking approach, McCallum emphasized the importance of adhering to established engineering principles to safeguard industry professionals and the submersible’s passengers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings

Mastering ChatGPT and Maximizing Workplace Productivity in the Digital Era

Keynote Address by Ed Walters at the AILA 2023 Annual Conference